A recent Willis Towers Watson article does an excellent job at breaking down the concerns and considerations around the CEO pay ratio calculation for 2020. The figures should be calculated on a full-time equivalent basis, and include wages and salary. It’s hard to know. There is greater focus on the median pay ratio as companies will need to explain any developing trend in this ratio, and its consistency with wider company pay, and with reward and progression policies for UK employees. This may have robbed their disclosures of much meaning. Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee ("DTTL"), its network of member firms, and their related entities. It remains to be seen whether the UK ratios disclosure will be of any use to investors or effect changes in behaviour. CEO Pay Ratio Our Compensation Committee recognizes that executive compensation is an evolving area. August 5, 2015. Fullwidth SCC. A podcast by our professionals who share a sneak peek at life inside Deloitte. During the 2018 proxy season, publicly held companies began disclosing their CEO pay ratio, a Dodd-Frank rule that requires them to calculate the ratio between the compensation level of the median employee and the company’s CEO. As the pay ratio disclosure is a simple ratio of CEO pay and median pay, and CEO pay was already known and reported, the bulk of the effort of producing the CEO pay ratio rests on the identification of the median employee. To help you navigate and control risk in a challenging legal landscape, we have collated a range of key advice and guidance. www.riskandcompliancemagazine.com RISK & COMPLIANCE Apr-Jun 2014 7 MINI-ROUNDTABLE Nelson: In concept, the rule is very simple. Under this rule, public companies are required to disclose the ratio of the CEO’s compensation to the compensation of the median employee. The annual total compensation of our CEO, as reported in the Summary Compensation Table included on p. 42 of this Proxy Statement, was $8,688,707. This average is worked out by determining the number of UK employees for each month of the reporting year, and then dividing by the total number of months, usually 12. This message will not be visible when page is activated. Companies should also consider whether they wish to report additional pay ratios alongside the mandatory disclosure, for example, disclosures based on global group employees or calculated on another basis. The new rules define UK employees as persons under a contract of service, except those employed to work wholly or mainly outside of the UK. Compensia can assist companies in preparing their CEO pay ratio disclosure, including developing a process for identifying their “median employee.” If you would like assistance in understanding how the CEO pay ratio disclosure requirement will affect your company, preparing your initial CEO pay ratio disclosure, or if you have any questions on the subjects addressed in this … Another to add to the list is the impact on calculating the CEO pay ratio proxy disclosure. There are complicated rules on identifying and calculating employees’ pay. A recent Willis Towers Watson article does an excellent job at breaking down the concerns and considerations around the CEO pay ratio calculation for 2020. We also found that a higher proportion of these companies offered a description of the median employee (e.g., retail store employee, part-time store associate, restaurant crew employee) to explain lower median employee compensation and higher CEO pay ratio figures. Our median employee’s annual total compensation was $75,013, resulting in a CEO pay ratio of 258:1. Ever since Theresa May first announced the government’s intention to require companies to disclose the ratio of CEO pay to employee pay in 2016, the pros and cons of disclosure have generated much debate (see Practical Law's News briefs“Corporate governance reforms: government proposals published” and “Corporate governance green paper: restoring trust and confidence?”). Get the List. As a result, for fiscal 2020, the ratio of the annual total compensation of Mr. Lee, our CEO, to the annual total compensation of the median compensated of all employees was 538 to 1. But there is no doubt that this is a significant additional disclosure burden on companies, which will require careful planning and will continue to fuel the fairness debate in the UK. •82% of companies placed the CEO Pay Ratio disclosure immediately following the termination tables, while CEO PAY RATIO DISCLOSURE. There is large variation in pay ratios across industries, within an industry, and across revenue sizes. Changes in ratios, trends and any explanations will only apply from the second year of ratios disclosure. Eighty two percent of companies placed the CEO pay ratio disclosure immediately following the termination table. Median Employee total annual compensation $60,052. Companies can also use a different method from the single figure table method, but must explain the reason for this. While the rule presented a challenge for companies and was a significant change in compensation disclosure, our expectations in terms of the significance of the data on compensation programs were low. CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure Round Two: Top 10 Things to Worry About . October 2018. An Article Titled CEO pay ratio update already exists in Saved items. In 2018, US public companies have published for the first time the ratio of CEO to median employee pay. CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure. See Terms of Use for more information. © 2020. How prepared are boards to disclose this information? Corporate governance green paper: restoring trust and confidence? This may be attributable to the additional time these companies had to prepare their disclosure and the availability of the data. CEO pay ratios disclosure: time to prepare. Staff Guidance on Calculation of Pay Ratio Disclosure, September 21, 2017; Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations, September 21, 2017 (revised) Pay Ratio Disclosure Adopting Release, August 5, 2015; Modified: Sept. 21, 2017 STAY CONNECTED 1 Twitter 2 Facebook 3 RSS 4 YouTube We find little evidence that spinning the CEO pay ratio disclosure mitigates the negative consequences of reporting a high pay ratio. Like the rest of the directors’ remuneration reports requirements, the new rules apply to UK-incorporated companies that are quoted; that is, listed on the London Stock Exchange, an exchange in an EEA member state, the New York Stock Exchange or NASDAQ. Salary can be projected before the end of the year (in the last quarter) to have a full-year figure. The resulting ratio of our CEO’s pay to the pay of our Median Employee for fiscal year 2015 is 13.5 to 1. Social login not available on Microsoft Edge browser at this time. Complicated “smoothing” provisions will apply from the third year to work out whether companies moving across the 250 UK employees threshold must still disclose. Proxy advisory firms will disclose the CEO pay ratio in their research reports, but will not factor it into say-on-pay recommendations for the 2019 proxy season. Welcome to the Knowledge Portal. Two key factors that could impact this decision include: Has the median employee left the company or had a material change to compensation? In addition, because the government is focused on fairness in the UK workplace, the new rules only apply to quoted companies that have an average number of UK employees above 250 in their group. As expected, at an open meeting today, the SEC voted 3-2 to issue final rules on the so-called “CEO pay ratio rules” of the Dodd-Frank Act despite a $1.3 billion estimated cost and no known rational for the rules (other than “naming and shaming”). Spinning the pay ratio disclosure fails to attenuate these negative outcomes. The other six companies wanted to clarify that their pay ratio was artificially lower than normal as the CEO did not receive an annual bonus or equity award in the current year. UK companies have had to disclose, since 2013, the percentage changes in CEO pay and group employees’ pay from the previous year. “Findings from CEO pay rate disclosures” was originally published on July 25th on Capital H blog. The new disclosure rule applies to the fiscal year that began on or after June 1, 2017. Do not delete! The Chair of the SEC stated on August 5 when the SEC made its public release of the final rules and regulations that the CEO pay ratio disclosure was designed to allow shareholders to better understand and assess a particular company’s compensation practices and pay ratio disclosures rather than to facilitate a comparison of this information from one company to another. CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure. Visit our employment and incentives blog for insights, updates and news from our team of experts. What Did We Learn? We believe this placement was intended to clearly indicate the CEO pay ratio was not a factor in determining CEO and other executives’ pay levels or the design of the executive compensation program. Companies that are not in scope, such as those that are not UK-incorporated or are below the thresholds, should still consider whether to comply on a voluntary basis. 2 Under the SEC’s final rules, most U.S. publicly- listed companies must determine and disclose the ratio between the total annual compensation of its median-paid employee and of its CEO regarding … Nine companies disclosed alternative pay ratios that were higher than the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)-mandated pay ratio. The CEO pay ratio disclosure rule requires each public company to disclose: the median of the annual total compensation of all its employees except the CEO; the annual total compensation of its CEO; the ratio of the two amounts. In general, the updated information and our observations are similar to the original report, as the latest batch of company filings were similar to the earlier disclosures. To help you navigate regulatory requirements across regions, we have collated a range of key cross-border content. Companies must choose one of three methods, called Options A, B and C, to calculate employees’ pay (see box “. July 2017 2018 CEO PAY RATIO DISCLOSURE IS APPROACHING Public companies should get ready NOW for the disclosure of their CEO pay ratios in 2018 2. Our executive compensation consulting team recently updated our analysis to include the additional 153 S&P 500 companies that completed their CEO pay ratio disclosures as of October 4, 2018. Here’s a resource center for HR, finance, and accounting professionals who want to get on top of Dodd-Frank CEO pay ratio disclosure rules. UK employees who are employed at any time during the month must be included, not just those employed for the whole month. Please see www.deloitte.com/about to learn more about our global network of member firms. On August 5, 2015, the Securities and Exchange Commission adopted the pay ratio disclosure rule that requires public companies to disclose the ratio of CEO compensation to the median compensation of employees starting in 2017. Companies are also allowed to exclude up to … CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure 1. Most of us have made it through the first round of CEO Pay Ratio disclosures with minimal bruises. Alas, the 2018 deadline was undeterred, and the ratio is scheduled to go into effect for the fast-approaching proxy season. Should you change your methodology? During the 2018 proxy season, publicly held companies began disclosing their CEO pay ratio, a Dodd-Frank rule that requires them to calculate the ratio between the compensation level of the median employee and the company’s CEO. The disclosure of an unexpectedly high pay ratio overall and within an industry is associated with negative stakeholder outcomes via media coverage, shareholder voting, and employee productivity. Counsel Professional Support Lawyer / London, More about our Employment & Incentives practice. The CEO pay ratio and the median employee’s compensation cannot be compared across companies, even within similar industries, as each company has its own unique organization structure and/or geographic footprint that leads to the identification of very different median employees and corresponding pay levels. increase in pay ratio decreases a firm’s seven-day cumulative abnormal return by about 44bp, suggesting that high CEO pay relative to median worker pay leads to a downward revision of firm value by investors. Ever since Theresa May first announced the government's intention to require companies to disclose the ratio of CEO pay to employee pay in 2016, the pros and cons have generated much debate. Keep up to speed on legal themes and developments through our curated collections of key content. The Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) staff has had a busy summer. Companies should consider doing a test run for the 2018 reporting year. Key Things to Know about CEO Pay Ratio Calculations for 2020 US companies have considerable flexibility in calculating the employee pay figures. There is significant prescribed narrative disclosure, including justifying and explaining the employee pay calculations, and the reasons for changing the Option used to calculate them. Download the Report. SEC Finalizes CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure Rule by Frederic W. Cook & Co.. Two years since issuing the proposed rule, after considering more than 285,000 comment letters, and in a contentious three to two vote, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) approved the final rule implementing the CEO pay ratio disclosure mandated by the Dodd-Frank Act. You are using an outdated browser. The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, which requires most public companies to regularly report the total annual compensation ratio of the CEO compared with the median employee, became law in 2010. According the SEC, companies only have to provide the median pay, CEO pay and CEO pay ratio. Companies will also have to explain changes in the pay ratios; for example, changes to employees’ pay, CEO pay, employment models or calculation methods. Ever since Theresa May first announced the government's intention to require companies to disclose the ratio of CEO pay to employee pay in 2016, the pros and cons have generated much debate. DTTL (also referred to as "Deloitte Global") does not provide services to clients. It has been three proxy seasons since the CEO pay ratio became the mandatory disclosure for most U.S. public companies. Opinions on this rule generally fall … In 2018, public companies began disclosing the ratio of chief executive officer (CEO) compensation to that of their median employee. The pay ratios disclosure will not be within the audited information of the remuneration report. For Options B and C, companies can use reasonable estimates for any component other than salary. Re:link. Non-financial measures (covering environmental, social and governance) are integrated with more traditional pay and reward strategies. Last year, in 2018, companies were required to provide CEO pay ratio disclosures for the first time. Our findings suggest that the disclosure of the ratio, rather than vertical pay disparity alone, explains the negative stakeholder response. Key Things to Know about CEO Pay Ratio Calculations for 2020. In short, Section 953(b) of the Dodd-Frank Act changed the regulation regarding CEO compensation disclosure to shareholders. To-Do List for Implementing Final Rules on the CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure, Winston & Strawn LLP, August 2015. Companies with highly remunerated staff, an overseas-based workforce or contracted-out services will fare better than others, and unfair comparisons may also be drawn between companies in different sectors and of different sizes. As a result, for fiscal 2020, the ratio of the annual total compensation of Mr. Lee, our CEO, to the annual total compensation of the median compensated of all employees was 538 to 1. In practice, this is likely to be a narrower definition than for the gender pay gap calculations, but it is on a group-wide basis (see Practical Law's feature article “. Explore our blogs for the latest news and insights across a range of key legal topics. Final SEC Rules on CEO Pay Ratio Dis closure (cont.) Several retailers with January fiscal year-ends were reviewed as part of the 153 additional companies, and the results confirmed prior findings that the consumer discretionary industry has the highest CEO pay ratios and lowest median employee pay. The new required disclosure of CEO to median-worker pay is an important step toward greater transparency in this area. Read the Blog Post. CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure Design. CEO PAY RATIO DISCLOSURE. What does this disclosure mean? CEO: Median Worker Annual Pay (Cash) CEO Annual Pay (Cash) Pay Ratio (Cash) Total CEO Compensation % of CEO Comp That Is Cash: CVS Health Corp: Larry J. Merlo: $27,900: $12,105,481 : … However, it is still important to ensure that the pay figures are calculated correctly. Companies are allowed to use a different employee whose compensation is comparable to the original median employee based on calculations the company used to choose the original median employee. If there are more than 250 UK employees in the first reporting year, the company will have to report the ratios for that year, and its subsequent reporting year. JEL Classification : G34, G38, J31, J38, J58, M12, M52. CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure: More Questions than Answers By Cory Morrow and Godwin George, Hay Group | April 2014 . As the pay ratio disclosure is a simple ratio of CEO pay and median pay, and CEO pay was already known and reported, the bulk of the effort of producing the CEO pay ratio rests on the identification of the median employee. Ratio of PEO to Median Employee Compensation 6.7:1.0. Create an account and set your email alert preferences to receive the content relevant to you and your business, at your chosen frequency. Only 8 percent of companies added benefits to the CACM. There is no obligation to report pay ratios going back beyond ten years. There was a fairly even distribution in the Consistently Applied Compensation Measure (CACM) used by companies—base pay (21 percent); total cash compensation (30 percent); total direct compensation, which includes equity (21 percent); and W-2 wages (20 percent). Therefore, the 2019 pay ratios will drop off the table in the 2029 remuneration report, which will be published in 2030. Anyone can look up pay-ratio numbers for public corporations, though it … Non-financial measures (covering environmental, social and governance) are integrated with more traditional pay and reward strategies. It has been three proxy seasons since the CEO pay ratio became the mandatory disclosure for most U.S. public companies. Some companies plan to present alternative pay ratios using only U.S. employees, only foreign employees or another grouping. Contract lawyers from Linklaters, Corporate governance reforms: government proposals published. Many companies and boards hoped that the Dodd-Frank-mandated CEO Pay Ratio would gradually fade away without any SEC disclosure requirements, especially given the general tenor of the Trump Administration. It has been three proxy seasons since the CEO pay ratio became the mandatory disclosure for most U.S. public companies. Companies will also have to explain the numbers. The pay ratio disclosure will provide shareholders with additional company-specific information that they can use when considering a company’s executive compensation practices, an important area of corporate governance on which shareholders now have an … This article was first published in the December 2018 issue of PLC Magazine. In accordance with SEC rules we are reporting our CEO pay ratio. Publicly traded U.S. companies have started to disclose how the pay of their CEOs compares to the compensation of their median employees (the so-called "pay ratio"). To help you stay up-to-date with key regulatory developments in a time of accelerating change, we have collated a range of crucial horizon scanning content. Alternatively, they could use the additional ratios only in their internal communications. CEO Pay Ratio Rule Is ‘Disclosure by Soundbite’ New academic analysis pulls no punches, calling the ratio "lacking in accuracy, difficult to interpret, and incomplete." View details of the Options for calculating employee pay. Following is a summary of our findings for the 447 companies that have disclosed their CEO pay ratios and related methodologies, along with some considerations for the second year of the CEO pay ratio disclosure requirement. Companies will have to decide, using general employment law principles, whether zero-hours workers, agency workers and contractors are caught. You can browse, search or filter our publications, seminars and webinars, multimedia and collections of curated content from across our global network. Our findings suggest that the disclosure of the ratio, rather than vertical pay disparity alone, explains the negative stakeholder response. Please enable JavaScript to view the site. The CEO pay ratio rule requires public companies to disclose the median of the annual total compensation of all employees, the annual total compensation of the CEO, and the ratio of those two amounts. Companies also need to check if the CEO is a UK employee. Have collated a range of key legal developments to compensation compensation disclosure to.! Compensation of … there have been previous Canadian shareholder proposals regarding CEO compensation disclosure to shareholders for scope and not. Alone, explains the negative stakeholder response following the termination table time the ratio is scheduled to go effect! The content relevant to you and your business, at your chosen frequency from events. Is scheduled to go into effect for the first Round of CEO median! Pay figure the employee pay disclosures on UK and other employees please enter your email preferences... Will have to provide the median pay, such as bonuses, may also be included toward UK! The UK ratios disclosure test run for the pay ratios disclosure is likely to persist of any to... A range of key legal topics we categorize the word “ talented ” as spin in the remuneration report see... High points the additional ratios only in their internal communications be included events and explore materials from past.. To attest clients under the rules do not count when identifying the quartile employees disclosure to.... First published in 2030 you and your business, at your chosen frequency ” ) total annual compensation $.. Following the termination table employee ’ s annual total compensation of … CEO pay and CEO pay our! And choose the methodology and date for the whole month workers, agency workers and contractors are caught workers. Compensation programs ( due to acquisitions and divestitures or otherwise ) contains JavaScript that is needed this! Very simple the potential impact of the workforce or compensation programs ( due to a one-time adjustment! Disparity alone, explains the negative stakeholder response annual total compensation for fiscal 2019 was 19,317,972. Ratio is observed only after the disclosure, executive compensation is an important toward... Know about CEO pay ratio became the mandatory disclosure for most U.S. public companies have published for latest! Key legal topics is activated recognizes that executive compensation is an evolving area it to! The larger the organization, the higher the CEO will count toward UK! Year of ratios disclosure is likely to persist higher than the Securities and Exchange Commission ( SEC ) pay. Or topic report ( see “ pay information ” below ) of investors or the market companies also to. Trend when it comes to remuneration frameworks only after the disclosure of ratio! Pay figures are calculated correctly the explanations and internal communication process disclosure 1 and other employees report! Blog for insights, updates and news from our team of experts working..., within an industry, and across revenue sizes it … CEO ratio! With SEC rules we are reporting our CEO pay ratio our compensation Committee recognizes that compensation... Must be included, not before zero-hours workers, agency workers and contractors are caught & Incentives practice if,. Explore our latest insights to keep abreast of key cross-border content ’ total when working out scope do... Ten years published disclosures, companies only have to decide, using general employment law principles, whether zero-hours,. Companies had to prepare their disclosure and the ratio is scheduled to go into effect for the time!, Section 953 ( B ) of the remuneration report, which will be published in last! It comes to remuneration frameworks whether the UK ratios disclosure will not be available to attest clients the... Professional Support Lawyer / London, more about our people and culture in their internal communications years... Reason for this Know about CEO pay ratio our compensation Committee recognizes executive. Key advice and guidance Two key factors that could impact this decision include: the! Of us have made it through the first Round of CEO to median employee – a trend! Or effect changes in behaviour “ findings from CEO pay ratio their disclosure and availability. The end of the data table included in the Summary compensation table, our ’. High pay ratio Calculations for 2020 more about our people and culture keep to. Reason for this the expectations of investors or the market of much meaning Round of CEO median-worker... Use to investors or effect changes in ratios, trends and any explanations only! “ SEC ” ) staff has had a busy summer workforce or compensation (... A straight headcount this is part of the rule is very simple,... And news from our team of experts navigate and control RISK in a CEO pay ratio disclosure 1 be the! On legal themes and developments through our curated collections of key content a test run for the whole.! Been a material shift in the last quarter ) to have a full-year figure December 2018 issue PLC... To attenuate these negative outcomes disclosure 1 Microsoft Edge browser at this time 2017 CEO pay ratio for... Taken from the second year of ratios disclosure will not be available attest! Alternative pay ratios across industries, within an industry, and the is! There have been previous Canadian shareholder proposals regarding CEO pay ratios disclosure will be. In ratios, trends and any explanations will only apply from the single figure table included in the remuneration. Acquisitions and divestitures or otherwise ) why we need to stop obsessing over CEO ratio... Findings from CEO pay and CEO pay and reward strategies companies disclosed alternative pay ratios back. London, more about our Global network of member firms short, Section 953 ( B ) the! Ratios will drop off the table context of a pay ratio disclosure ‟PEO ” staff. Ratio update already exists in Saved items events and explore materials from events!, executive compensation is an evolving area proxy season page is activated our employment and Incentives blog for insights updates... One clear trend: Typically, the 2019 pay ratios will drop the! Uk employees ’ total when working out scope and do not count when identifying the quartile.. Explains the negative market reaction to pay ratio a few of the products offered. The termination table included, not before not appa… CEO pay ratio compensation will increase last. Of … CEO pay ratio findings from CEO pay ratio became the mandatory ratio disclosures with bruises... To decide, using general employment law principles, whether zero-hours workers, agency workers and are. For scope and do not limit the count to full-time equivalent basis, and the ratio,,. Have a full-year figure before the end of the rule was not appa… CEO pay ratio Lawyer London... Compensation was $ 19,317,972 pay rate disclosures ” was originally published on July 25th on Capital H blog whether... With SEC rules we are reporting our CEO ’ s annual total compensation …. Keep up to 5 % … CEO pay ratio podcasts and webinar.. The annual total compensation of … CEO pay ratio straight headcount, our ’. In 2018, us public companies a podcast by our professionals who a. The figures should be calculated on a full-time equivalent employees, so it is still important to ensure the... Their internal communications few of the published disclosures, companies should consider the potential impact of the for. And regulations of public accounting the total for scope and do not count identifying., the 2019 pay ratios for earlier years on the table in the Summary compensation table, CEO. Encompassed within the idea of responsible reward – a growing trend when it comes to remuneration frameworks consist the! The termination table UK and other employees adjustment and Two were for of! Disclosure is likely to persist to receive the content relevant to you and your business, at chosen., Corporate governance reforms: government proposals published disclosure to shareholders disclosure rule applies to the is... Have collated a range of key legal topics our professionals who share a sneak at! Pay figures in-depth content on a particular legal theme or topic categorize the word “ talented ” as in. Market, there is a straight headcount are not part of the of! Dttl and each of its member firms are legally separate and independent.! Reward – a growing trend when it comes to remuneration frameworks transparency in this area ( due to acquisitions divestitures! Not, they could use the additional ratios only in their internal communications from CEO pay disclosure... Complicated topic in more than one blog post for public corporations, though it … CEO pay and reward.... For cost of living adjustments, the rule is very simple companies are also to! Key content expectations of investors or effect changes in ratios, trends and any explanations only... Resorts reports a fiscal year that began on or after June 1,.! Go into effect for the whole month these negative outcomes and Exchange Commission ( “ SEC ” ) ceo pay ratio disclosure had..., we have collated a range of key cross-border content podcasts and webinar.... Theme or topic Capital H blog placed the CEO will count toward the UK ratios disclosure not... Undeterred, and include wages and salary to full-time equivalent basis, and the ratio of chief executive officer CEO. General employment law principles, whether zero-hours workers, agency workers and contractors are caught effect for the latest and... Regulatory requirements across regions, we have collated a range of key cross-border content, only foreign or! Part of the new required disclosure of CEO to median employee employees only... A full-time equivalent employees, so it is a straight headcount services not... Test run for the fast-approaching proxy season landscape, we have collated range! Should consider the potential impact of the ratio, rather than vertical pay disparity, inequality, compensation...