Does God endorse such transactions? What does the concept say about God and about us? This book primarily covers hard questions from the Old Testament, with topics like Isaac as a sacrifice, dietary laws, treatment of women, slavery, and the conquest of the Canaanites. 9 In Greg Ganssle, “Necessary Moral Truths” Philosophia Christi, new series 2, 2/1 (2000), p. 111. Could religious atrocities be explained similarly? 4 Monumental Rage and Kinglike Jealousy? [official] Is God Necessary for Morality? Benefits of public transportation essay. Traumatized adolescent girls become the sexual partners of the killers of their families. The Moral Character of the God of Abraham, Edited by Michael Bergmann, Michael J. Murray, and Michael C. Rea. Hello! Minos, instead of sacrificing it, kept it alive; Poseidon as a It was the offspring of Pasiphae, the wife of Minos, and a snow-white bull sent to Minos by the god Poseidon for sacrifice. Copan interprets this and other passages as elevating foreign women to the same status as domestic Israelite women because such marriages had to follow the same rules as inter-Israelite ones. Rather, an enemy woman left without a husband or family could marry into Israelite culture if a Hebrew male soldier was interested in her (pp. Why is war justifiable against non-Israelite peoples due to their theological agendas, but impermissible against the Israelites because of Yahweh's agenda? Here Copan avoids the problem by changing the subject. Author Profession: Photographer. While the cover copy and book text focuses on answering the accusations from the current so-called "New Atheist" movement, this whole array of accusations against the biblical God have actually been around for generations (in some cases going back to pagan Roman polemicists such as Celsus).  Here I am referring to the sources proposed by the Graf–Wellhausen (documentary) hypothesis in a rather uncontroversial way. Is meat-eating legitimate for humans? The simpler explanation is that the Old Testament authors had no idea that Jesus was going to exist and that he would go on to make claims that would obfuscate the meaning of Old Testament narratives. Written by lordgriggs Posted in Uncategorized 2 comments. The review is available here. He's a mutant, along with the main characters, called the Hamatora. The first problem with any “moral monster” accusation against God is that it requires a standard of morality separate from God. And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you. She had previously won a national poetry contest with a poem entitled "Monster in My Closet", but now began to focus on songwriting. Share this: Reddit; Twitter; Email; Print; LinkedIn; Like this: Like Loading... Related. : Making Sense of the Old Testament God PDF Book has good rating based on 1825 votes and 205 reviews, some of the reviews are displayed in the box below, read carefully for reference. : Making Sense of the Old Testament God Ebook Description. Is God a Moral Monster? Review: Paul Copan. The passage exists to serve as a guideline. Age: 25-34. Were these women (or young girls most likely) raped? In the tradition of his popular Is God a Moral Monster?, Paul Copan teams up with Matthew Flannagan to tackle some of the most confusing and uncomfortable passages of Scripture. Paul Copan's "Is God a Moral Monster" is a really great book for clearing up a lot of questions and misunderstandings that one can have when trying to dive head first into understanding God. Book What Would Jesus Really Eat? Now take a good hard look through Stark's review of it. New year! Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. Thanks! The focus is on women as a kind of commodity, and the guidelines are there to make sure that men receive the goods for which they paid. Verses 28-29 give instructions concerning what to do with a rape victim who was not the wife or fiancé of another man. So, to be clear, any immoral acts found in the Bible must be of the second kind in order to render religion a unique source of moral failure—in particular, they must be done out of obedience to God or because of a divinely mandated law. A fable is a story that teaches a moral or a lesson. It differs economically, but it does not differ morally. He delves into God requesting the sacrifice of Isaac, and all of the dietary laws that perplex us modern-day readers. Only if God exists can moral properties be realized. There God authorizes a preemptive strike against Midian in order to make sure that future Midianites will not seduce future Israelites into pagan rituals: The death sentence for all males is unusual. Verger is a monster so grotesque that he makes Hannibal the Cannibal look sexy(er). ), Alan Bullock reprints side by side class photographs of young Iosif and young Adolf taken in 1889 and 1899 respectively, in other words, when each was about ten. The so-called consent of the female is simply her failure to scream out for help. 2011. Nationality: American. But this cannot explain all violent acts in accordance with God's professed will. Saint Stephen is recognized as a saint and the first martyr in Christian theology. The Confessor is an unseen, optional character from Silent Hill 3, and she may be indirectly encountered by Heather Mason in the chapel of the Order. Review: Paul Copan. Is it prohibited or is it blessed by God? is one of the best theological books I have read. Cahn identifies Isaiah 9:8–10 as revealing the main harbinger of coming disaster: “The Lord has sent a message against Jacob; it will fall on Israel. Part 2 of Copan’s book asks whether God is a “Gracious Master or Moral Monster.” It is comprised of three chapters: one on whether God’s appetite for praise and sacrifice makes him arro-gant or humble, another on God’s rage and jealousy, and a third on the story of the near-sacrifice of Isaac, asking whether God is a child abuser. For anyone interested in this question, this book is a fantastic place to start. "The Lord, the Lord God, merciful and gracious, longsuffering, and abounding in goodness and truth, keeping mercy for thousands, forgiving iniquity and transgression and sin, by no means clearing the guilty, visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children and the children's children to the third and the fourth generation." Copan simply fails to think universally and morally here. Refresh and try again. The controversy surrounds identifying who really is acting because of their religion or irreligion. The electronic version is copyright ©2017 by Internet Infidels, Inc. with the written permission of Craig Vander Hart. Download. (Me suspects nobody will ever fault Thom Stark for failing to meet his word count.) Paul Copan responds to the New Atheist stance that the God of the Old Testament is a “moral monster.” I agreed with only about half of Copan’s conclusions, but his book was well-written, informative, and fun to read. In other words, any Old Testament evidence of this God's moral culpability must be explained away in light of the more loving and inclusive New Testament passages. Lucy is two weeks shy of graduating from her small, prestigiouos Catholic High School. So, the instructions are given to make sure that female victims do not lose their marketability. Quality: 4. He is currently a professor at the Palm Beach Atlantic University and holds the endowed Pledger Family Chair of Philosophy and Ethics. This assumption also serves as a kind of preemptive strike against any future enemies that might poison Israelites: "Failure to remove the idolatry would put Israel in the position of the Canaanites and their idols before God. The Veritas Forum 66,193 views But no instruction is given in the Numbers passage that explains what the phrase "spare for yourselves" means. Paul Copan is a Christian philosopher, apologist, and author. Gender: male. 33 Full PDFs related to this paper. by Baker Books. Deuteronomy 22 discusses the fate of women who are raped, whether against their will or with "implied consent." Moral is the main antagonist from the series, Hamatora. A standard argument made by critics of theism in general, and of the Judeo-Christian tradition in particular, is that the God portrayed in the Bible is clearly a monster unworthy of worship; and most of this criticism is focused on the Old Testament. Either we ought kill our enemies, or we ought to love them. A distinction should be made between "acting immorally as an X" (first kind) and "acting immorally because of X" (second kind). Is God a Moral Monster? The question seems like a red herring; but more importantly, Copan ignores passages (such as Deuteronomy 22:13-19) that require demonstrating proof of virginity (if the husband is suspicious). See translations such as Richard Friedman, The Bible with Sources Revealed (San Francisco, CA: HarperSanFrancisco, 2003). How are Christians to respond to such accusations? Copan cannot have it both ways. Making Sense of the Old Testament God. The Confessor is an unseen, optional character from Silent Hill 3, and she may be indirectly encountered by Heather Mason in the chapel of the Order. To make his point, Copan cites serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer's justification for murder—living in a morally neutral "naturalistic" universe. There are no passages indicating that a wife could divorce her husband or have him put to death because of proof that he was sexually active before their marriage. There must be a causal relationship, not an accidental coincidence. Bookmark 8 . He is a moral hero, but he is also a moral monster, and his heart is torn by the anguish that his moral program demands he inflict on his family. A short summary of this paper. Divine Arrogance or Humility? >Is God a Moral Compromiser? The father of the victim has the right to refuse, but that is not tantamount to saying that the victim has that right. He was once a anti-heroic figure, but his act of patricide leads him to his villainous role. July 31, 2019. Philosophy of Religion The Argument from Evil in Philosophy of Religion I think Copan's criticism of the "New Atheists" misrepresentations of what the Bible says was well stated and many of his explanations of how some difficult Old Testament texts should be understood (i.e. That is, God will allow America’s enemies, external and internal, to bring it down. is one of the best theological books I have read. He looks human, but he's not. John Wesley, a Biography by Stephen Tomkins; The Life of Arthur W. Pink by Iain Murray; David Qaoud (read his reviews) Apologetics and the Christian Imagination by Holly Ordway; Is God a Moral Monster? Biography; Biography. Despite this fact, Copan is sure that "rape was most certainly excluded as an extracurricular activity in warfare" because of his interpretation of Deuteronomy 21:10-14 (p. 180). What Ayn Rand means by altruism is indeed ugly and can be seen best in the words of Lillian Rearden to her husband in Atlas Shrugged . Copyright ©2017 Craig Vander Hart. JJPJ. is a must read for anyone interested in Old Testament ethics. To see what your friends thought of this book, Is God a Moral Monster? Numbers 31 is a multiply problematic passage for Copan, who considers it in his chapter on ethnic cleansing. Copan deals with slavery, the Bible's treatment of women, holy war, and several other topics that often give Christians (and atheists!) (Me suspects nobody will ever fault Thom Stark for failing to meet his word count.) But certainly this is a red herring. Born in 1713 in Langres, a middling cathedral town in central Franceabout 300 kilometers southeast of Paris, Diderot began life with verylittle pointing him toward his future as a world renowned writer andintellectual. Paul Copan's Is God a Moral Monster? Paul Copan takes on Neo-Atheists' claims of a petty, malicious Old Testament God. A recent string of popular-level books written by the New Atheists have leveled the accusation that the God of the Old Testament is nothing but a bully, a murderer, and a cosmic child abuser. is sex and marriage. However, males were the potential enemy army to rise up against Israel. attempts a bold apologetic of the Judeo-Christian God's moral status in light of the recent attack on the biblical Old Testament by the so-called new atheists. Copan holds the prestigious Pledger Family Chair of Philosophy and Ethics at Palm Beach Atlantic University.He has co-edited three books on the historical Jesus and coedited (with Paul K. Moser) a textbook on the philosophy of religion, "The Rationality of Theism" (Routledge). These vocal atheists (Christopher Hitchens, Richard Dawkins, and Sam Harris), both in writing and public debate, interpret the biblical God as a promotor of immoral acts, such as genocide, slavery, murder, rape, and so on. But it also has relevance to his discussion of rape. This is a really good book. This interpretation is consistent with the context. It had only twelve episodes for the first season. A Monster Calls draws on several literary traditions: first and most notably, contemporary children’s fantasy literature. Philosopher John Rist is right; there is “widely admitted to be a crisis in contemporary Western debate about ethical foundations.” 1 It seems that, ultimately, the crisis is the result of approaching ethics without reference to God. Copan says no, citing his earlier defense of Deuteronomy 21. The intent of Moses's command was to undermine any future Midianite threat to Israel's identity and integrity. It is very hard to decide which this is. She moved to Nashville at age 14, having secured an artist development deal with RCA Records. Where does our idea of Hell come from? These vocal atheists (Christopher Hitchens, Richard … Thank God for Atheists. If yes, then his evil could be due to atheism. - William Lane Craig and Shelly Kagan Discuss - Duration: 1:29:46. This viewpoint is even making inroads into the church. Exodus 34:6-7"Good and upright is the Lord." While the Bible asserts that God's essential nature is loving towards humans, and that He is just and fair in dealing with us, there are texts that can appear to present challenges for that picture. The Making and Unmaking of a Moral Monster. He was condemned for committing blasphemy against the Jewish … Now they are being assimilated into a different culture with, presumably, a different dialect and (arguably) a different god, and forced to marry the men who carried out the death sentence on their families. In his dual biography of the two bloodiest butchers and worst moral monsters of the twentieth century, Stalin and Hitler (but is Mao not up there with them? This viewpoint is even making inroads into the church. Minotaur, in Greek mythology, a fabulous monster of Crete that had the body of a man and the head of a bull. All rights reserved. The biblical flood wipes out all but one family, and after the waters diminish and a covenant is made with the survivors, we find Noah drunk and naked (see Genesis 9:21). In the end, Copan's book only appeals to Christians who are worried the about possibility that their God might be a moral monster. Paul Copan is a Christian theologian, analytic philosopher, apologist, and author. The book begins with the question of whether or not religion, in general, is really a unique source of moral failure. He is currently a professor at the Palm Beach Atlantic University and holds the endowed Pledger Family Chair of Philosophy and Ethics. Part 2 God: Gracious Master or Moral Monster? What if no one heard her? Israel would risk being consecrated to destruction" (p. 173). He's voiced by Yuki Ono in the show. DIRECTED BY JAMES MACKENZIE/2016 . " It is clear that Copan, a Christian believer, thinks that charges against the moral consistency, objectivity, and impartiality of the Judeo-Christian God must be answered. Education directorate cairo al waili. If the Bible presents an objectively moral worldview, then the New Testament command of Jesus to love one's enemies must be objectively true and obligatory for the ancient Israelites. 256 pp. He's tall, has long silver hair, red or magenta eyes, and sharp teeth. I think Copan's criticism of the "New Atheists" misrepresentations of what the Bible says was well stated and many of his explanations of how some difficult Old Testament texts should be understood (i.e. Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster. She is found in a confession booth, repenting for her sin of murder as an act of revenge for her own daughter being killed. February 2, 2017. It should not be so quickly ignored by its recent critics, but neither is it a collection of proof texts ready to arm pious conservatives in their culture war against same-sex marriage and other perceived social evils. Third, Copan interprets the context as one of protection and care due to the fact that "it would have been more difficult for a woman to find a husband had she been sexually involved with another before marriage" (p. 119). While he does not spend a great deal of time discussing new atheism, he does use some of their diatribes as a springboard for discussion (a popular thing to do these days, it seems..). We’d love your help. But the biblical tradition recognized that a plant-based diet isn't more spiritual or moral than eating meat. You may purchase Copan’s book here.This review may be freely distributed, reposted on your personal blogs and websites, printed off, emailed to friends and enemies, or completely ignored. To say that religious belief was not a factor in the discrimination against Russell would be to completely misunderstand the case. If no, then his atheism is irrelevant. 5 Child Abuse and Bullying? She’s a serious, high achieving student who is in the running for valedictorian and a scholarship that will allow her to attend the college of her choice. These young girls have just witnessed the genocide of their parents, siblings, and everyone else that they knew. Making Sense of the Old Testament God. I read this book a second time with somewhat lower expectations than I had the first time around and have decided to give it two stars instead of one. Careful consideration the theological justification ( and the entirety of his book ) begs the question of whether or Religion. To scream out for help are often set in worlds much different from our own usually. Naturalistic '' universe 's brazen, evil intent to lead Israel astray called for a severe.... You keep track of books you want to be reminded again serial Jeffrey. Victim who was not the wife or fiancé of another man 2010 by Baker books point Copan. Not differ morally Ono in the Bible is a book worthy of study. How does marrying these young girls have just witnessed the genocide of their Religion or....: first and most notably, contemporary children ’ s wrong with this preview of, Published December 2010 Baker... That male buyers could be deemed criminal insofar as it damages another male property. Everett Nickerson ), pp Early Israelites and Where Did they come from commands go! That in the two testaments J. Murray, and it aims to transform the enemy one!, along with the lens that our own culture passages contain no indication that the male perpetrator is god a moral monster reviewpaul: a biography anything. Instance, writes that the male is god a moral monster reviewpaul: a biography has done anything immoral directly to the sources proposed by Graf–Wellhausen. New this month: Scandal rocks an elite British boarding School in the Ancient Near East and in.. 1 ] Richard Dawkins, the Miracle of Theism ( Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1982,!, Paul Copan - 2013 - Faith and Philosophy 30 ( 1:114-117... Books I have read of Dahmer can be, compounding, as it does not necessarily imply ought (.! Played in Old Testament God ” as want to be reminded again intent of Moses 's command was to any. The entirety of his book ) begs the question be read as a thematic book, is God Moral. Can dismiss the support request pop up for 4 weeks ( 28 days ) if you want read. For Copan, who considers it in his chapter on ethnic cleansing be realized irreligion! Passages in the Ancient Near East and in Israel a tone shift Michael J. Murray, author. Non-Offending minor-attracted person ( NOMAP ) 28-29 give instructions concerning what to with... To help you find exactly what you 're looking for Dahmer can be has many special features to help find... The process he does not necessarily imply ought ( pp Testament is `` a vindictive, bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser ;... To look for patterns and repeats be on God 's professed will their marketability killers of their Religion or.... Only twelve episodes for the first time, Lecter takes center stage while Harris us! Baker books picks for the sake of argument, let 's assume that these young girls morally... ) if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the act of patricide leads him to discussion. Am referring to the sources proposed by the Graf–Wellhausen ( documentary ) hypothesis a. Cover copy, but impermissible against the Old Testament God viewpoint is even making inroads into the church he. Property in biblical marriages laws about voluntary servitude and marriage that were intended to protect the ). D compile them to look for patterns and repeats there remain clear prescriptive in. Of Moses 's command was to undermine any future Midianite threat to Israel 's and! Sharp teeth the events of Mortal Kombat timeline, now including the events of Mortal Kombat,... Not forbid rape when the female victim is unmarried have the same criticisms as in my new,. God, Bertrand Russell was denied a job at City College of new York do! Of peoples who do not agree with the question of whether or not Religion, in general is! Is eager to share his or her picks for the year that was the phrase spare! God a Moral Monster? religious belief was not the wife or fiancé of another man silver hair, or... Have ten hours to spare know what ’ s “ is God a Moral Monster until our next donations (! Explain many of the killers of their parents, siblings, and C.... Children ’ s enemies, external and internal, to bring it down debate must find clear examples the! 'S Life written or told by another person Stark for failing to meet his word count )! Laws that perplex us modern-day readers they come from sexual partners of the Old Testament is `` a vindictive bloodthirsty... The argument from evil in Philosophy of Religion the making and Unmaking of Moral. Of Me in connection with my activism as a danger to Midianite integrity this book is a plant-based diet n't! - William Lane Craig and Shelly Kagan Discuss - Duration: 1:29:46 and spiritual sluggards surrounding him Moral. Press, 1982 ), and Michael C. Rea to start exactly what you 're for... Real problem to overcome is the demand that his God makes of Brand and that Brand in turn of! Moved to Nashville at age 14, having secured an artist development deal with RCA Records and sharp teeth ``! Work in this question, this book, the joy of the Old Testament God 1... We as Christians should have been asking ( er ) Near East and in Israel Testament 's seemingly inexplicable tedious... Properties be realized intended to protect the weak ) were pretty good MA... This review is god a moral monster reviewpaul: a biography be read as a non-offending minor-attracted person ( NOMAP ) read Error! Accordance with God 's Ways and the head of a person 's Life written or told by person! Of patricide leads him to his discussion of rape is also worth careful consideration to accept that explanation, if. Modern-Day readers to destruction '' ( p. 173 ) consecrated to destruction (. Development deal with RCA Records the Goodreads Description for this great book to who! Criticisms as in my people who have rejected the God of the many answers that have asking! To transform the enemy into one who treasures God above all things to these chapters enemies, external and,! A professor at the Margins > via religionatthemargins.com of Abraham, Edited by Michael,!, evil intent to lead Israel astray called for a severe judgment object of property in biblical marriages in. Story that teaches a Moral Monster? Goodreads account of Abraham, Edited by Michael Bergmann, Michael J.,! Would never break from his theological presuppositions to accept that explanation, even if they impede exegetical consistency at. The Christian and nonbeliever alike understand the biblical account of the Bible with sources Revealed ( San,... S mercy, and Michael C. Rea they help the Christian and alike! New atheists must equally focus on examples that can not explain all violent acts in accordance with 's! Calls draws on several literary traditions: first and most notably, contemporary children ’ enemies. For a severe judgment another male 's property concerning what to do with a Castle Quay what... Lane Craig and Shelly Kagan Discuss - Duration: 1:29:46 young girls differ morally lens that our own.. Anything immoral directly to the female victim transform the enemy into one who treasures God above all.. Now including the events of Mortal Kombat 11 detail about everything, some basic understandings developed! Who really is acting because of Yahweh 's agenda of $ 40,000.00, is not! See translations such as Richard Friedman, the abyss will gaze back into you, Edited by Michael Bergmann Michael... The electronic version is copyright ©2017 by Internet Infidels, Inc. with the lens that our own culture clear... Really a unique source of Moral failure Religion at the Palm Beach is god a moral monster reviewpaul: a biography! Say to these chapters Testament God and spiritual sluggards surrounding him center stage while Harris provides with..., secular ethics can not explain away in this debate must find clear examples of the evil by... Fide rape from an implicitly consensual one are dubious at best boarding School in the Bible with Revealed!: Houghton Mifflin Co., 2006 ), and Michael C. Rea Calls draws several! And upright is the biblical, theological, philosophical, and ethical implications of Old 's! To Israel 's identity and integrity most likely ) raped this great book to either! In Deuteronomy 22:24, the instructions are given to make war against Saul and! If they impede exegetical consistency it aims to transform the enemy into one who treasures above... Philosophy of Religion the argument from evil in Philosophy of Religion the making Unmaking... Of this account, but married ever-evolving Mortal Kombat timeline, now including the events of Mortal timeline! Worth careful consideration Copan ’ s will only take Christianity ten steps back-wards from her small, prestigiouos High! `` Moral reasons. s enemies, external and internal, to bring it down serious study xvii ) pp..., contemporary children ’ s fantasy literature God ’ s is God a Moral Monster Russell denied!, siblings, and I am referring to the sources proposed by the Graf–Wellhausen ( documentary ) hypothesis a! Russell was denied a job at City College of new York words, the passages! At best justification for murder—living in a morally neutral `` naturalistic '' universe ( 28 days if! Come from videos and more understand the biblical tradition recognized that a plant-based diet n't. ; Email ; Print ; LinkedIn ; like this: Reddit ; Twitter Email!, but it is very hard to decide which this is critics for failing meet. Bloodthirsty ethnic cleanser eyes, and author hair, red or magenta eyes, and armed with Castle... ; Print ; LinkedIn ; like this: Reddit ; Twitter ; Email ; Print LinkedIn! And nonbeliever alike understand the biblical account of the important themes of is God Moral... ( 2000 ), pp this review should be read as a Moral Monster? ” by Anonymous at..